Skip to main content
best anytime TD odds jonathan taylor

Happy Thursday! You’ve found my best NFL touchdown picks for Thursday. We’ve got an AFC South matchup between two organizations that probably expected to have more than three wins apiece by this point.

The Colts visit the Texans for Thursday Night Football, and despite their matching win totals, Houston is a 11.5-point favorite at Hard Rock Bet Sportsbook. The point total sits at 44.

Not exactly a ringing endorsement of the current situation in Indianapolis.

Still, an ugly matchup can give us some interesting touchdown prices. I’m backing a couple of familiar names and making a very small wager on a tight end whose role expanded last week.

Let’s get into my favorite NFL touchdown bets for Thursday, November 19.

Colts vs. Texans Anytime Touchdown Picks

  • Drew Ogletree Anytime TD +1750
  • Jonathan Taylor Anytime TD +120
  • Nico Collins Anytime TD +100

All referenced odds are subject to change.

New customers Bet $5 Get up to $500 in no sweat bets in game bonus powered by past motor racing

Drew Ogletree Anytime Touchdown (+1750)

We’re opening with the long shot, so let’s establish the wager size before we do anything else.

This is a baby bet – an entertainment-sized sprinkle. We’re not rearranging the monthly budget because I found a tight end at +1750. But hold the phone – there’s an actual role-based argument here.

Mo Alie-Cox and Will Mallory are out tonight. With Alie-Cox unavailable last week, Drew Ogletree played a season-high 51% of Indianapolis’ offensive snaps.

He was also on the field for 36% of the passing snaps, which was a little more involvement than I expected.

The most interesting part, though, is where he played. Ogletree was on the field for all three of the Colts’ snaps inside the 10-yard line and both snaps inside the 5.

Those are tiny samples, but for a player priced at better than 17-1, they’re relevant. We’re not guessing whether Indianapolis is willing to use him near the goal line. We just watched him get those snaps.

That doesn’t mean he was the intended receiver. He can spend the whole evening blocking and leave us with a very boring ticket. But he has four career touchdowns, and the injuries at his position create a reasonable path to more playing time.

With Indianapolis a substantial underdog, there’s also a scenario where the Colts spend a good portion of the game throwing.

I’m not projecting a pile of targets. One well-timed opportunity would do just fine.

I’m also putting an even smaller amount on Ogletree to score the first touchdown at +7500. That’s a separate, much more difficult outcome, especially with Indianapolis such a heavy underdog.

We’re talking a slice of pizza’s worth of money, not the whole delivery order.

The anytime touchdown pick is the main angle. The first-touchdown wager is a tiny extra for a player whose recent deployment gives us something more concrete than simply liking a giant number.

Jonathan Taylor Anytime Touchdown (+120)

Jonathan Taylor and I may need to have a conversation. Actually, I’d rather speak with whoever is deciding how Indianapolis uses him. Shane? Carlie? Anyone? Helloooooo!?

The Colts kept Taylor through the trade deadline, then continued operating with a timeshare. He played 68% of the snaps last week, which is a healthy number for plenty of running backs.

For Taylor, we’re accustomed to something closer to the workhorse treatment, often north of 80%.

I understand wanting to see more of Seth McGowan. He’s good at football. But if Taylor remains a major part of the long-term plan, I’m still trying to understand exactly what Indianapolis wants this backfield to look like.

That uncertainty is part of why we’re getting +120. I’m willing to live with it at this price.

Houston’s defense carries some name recognition, but the Texans rank in the bottom half of the league in defensive EPA per play this season. This isn’t a matchup where I’m automatically crossing off an opposing running back.

The bigger concern is Indianapolis itself. The Colts have moved pieces, the offense has lost firepower, and a double-digit spread tells us there may not be many comfortable possessions.

Still, if they reach the 5- or 10-yard line, I expect Taylor to get a chance to finish the drive. That’s an expectation, not a promise from the coaching staff, but he remains one of the best scoring options they have.

And if they decide to throw it to Ogletree instead, I suppose I’ll find a way to cope.

This isn’t the same bet as backing Taylor in a fully functioning offense with a dominant workload. The situation has changed, and the price reflects it. But since Indy didn’t trade this guy, they should pound the rock while the game is manageable.

Nico Collins Anytime Touchdown (+100)

C.J. Stroud deserves a ton of credit for what he’s doing this season.

Houston’s offense has thrived on explosive plays without any type of running game, and here’s a strange illustration of how it’s been operating: The Texans haven’t run a single snap inside the 5-yard line over their last two games. Not one – it just hasn’t been necessary.

They’ve been doing damage without needing the traditional goal-line finish, and Nico Collins is exactly the kind of receiver who can score before the offense gets anywhere near the doorstep.

Houston ranks above the league average in explosive plays, and Collins presents a difficult matchup regardless of where a possession starts.

He also has a strong history against Indianapolis. I’m not betting him solely because he’s hurt the Colts before, but it doesn’t make me less interested.

The current role is the bigger selling point.

Collins leads Houston’s skill-position players in snap share by a considerable margin. With Tank Dell continuing to work his way back, Collins is the clear top receiving threat.

And when Stroud does look into the end zone, the connection has been productive: Collins leads the Texans with six end-zone targets and five touchdowns on those opportunities.

Against a depleted Indianapolis defense, I’m comfortable taking Collins at even money.

Good luck with your Thursday Night Football touchdown bets! Play responsibly, especially with these longer-odds props.

More ways to play

If you’re already in on today’s action, Florida players can also check out Real Money Games powered by Past Motor Racing, only on Hard Rock Bet. It’s a way to play fast-paced, real money game titles that fit seamlessly alongside game day.

Offered by the Seminole Tribe of Florida in FL. Offered by Seminole Hard Rock Digital, LLC, in all other states. Must be 21+ and physically present in AZ, CO, FL, IL, IN, MI, NJ, OH, TN or VA to play. Terms and conditions apply. Concerned about gambling? In FL, call 1-833-PLAYWISE. In IN, if you or someone you know has a gambling problem and wants help, call 1-800-9-WITH-IT. In AZ, OH, & VA, call 1-800-MY-RESET.
GAMBLING PROBLEM? CALL 1‑800‑GAMBLER (CO, IL, MI, NJ, TN)

Justin Carlucci

Carlucci began his career in 2012 at Times News Media Group as a reporter and editor, later expanding its digital presence through video, podcasts, and sports radio. He moved into fantasy sports and betting in 2016, creating widely read analysis and hosting expert podcasts before joining Better Collective (RotoGrinders & Scores and Odds), where he developed multi-site content strategies and gained national exposure through the New York Post and SiriusXM. Most recently, he served as Managing Editor at Props.com, leading content strategy and brand media. Justin was a qualifier for the National Sports Betting Championship in 2020.