Skip to main content

College football has officially entered a new phase—and the playoff semifinals make that impossible to ignore. This is no longer a sport defined by logos, recruiting rankings, or which programs can stockpile five-star depth. It’s about where players want to live, develop, and play, and how quickly teams can evolve in a transfer-heavy world.

The matchups ahead—Miami vs. Ole Miss and Oregon vs. Indiana—aren’t just games. They’re case studies in how the sport is changing in real time.

Miami vs. Ole Miss: The SEC Depth Problem Is Real

Miami enters as a 3.5-point favorite with the spread, and we like them to win—but not in a shootout. This feels like a tight, physical game, something in the neighborhood of 24–23. Ole Miss is being framed as the clear underdog, the fourth team of four, but that narrative says more about the current state of the SEC than it does about Ole Miss itself.

The conference still has elite starters. What it no longer has is overwhelming depth.

That’s the part nobody wants to admit.

When players can get paid anywhere, the old hoarding model collapses. At 21 years old, are you choosing Tuscaloosa—or Miami? Austin? Los Angeles? That choice is reshaping rosters across the country.

Georgia is the clearest example. The talent is still there, but the margin for error is gone. Lose a receiver to a preseason transfer. Lose another to injury. Suddenly you’re thin. Five years ago, that didn’t matter. You had another NFL player waiting. Now you don’t.

We’ve seen it at Ohio State, too. Two running backs gone and suddenly an offense that looks… ordinary. Fourteen points here. Ten points there. That’s not dominance. That’s survival.

Ole Miss can absolutely hang in this game. They’ve got a quarterback who gives them a real shot. But Miami wins it because they’re built for what college football is becoming.

Why Miami Is Built for Modern College Football

This isn’t finesse Miami. This is a strong football team.

They hit. They intimidate. Their defensive line looks like a collection of future pros, and their secondary brings real force. If Indiana is the best tackling team in the country, Miami might be the most physically imposing.

What’s important is how different Miami looks now compared to midseason. You simply can’t judge transfer-heavy teams in October anymore. When you bring in eight, ten, or twelve key contributors, it takes time to gel.

Miami didn’t fully become Miami until late.

That Pittsburgh game—38–7—was the moment it clicked. Not because Pittsburgh is elite, but because of how Miami dominated them physically. They were throwing bodies around. That was grown-man football.

They’re no longer Carson Beck–dependent. They’re confident, physical, and comfortable in their identity. If they win this game, they likely earn a home game for the national championship—and at that point, their physicality absolutely travels.

Oregon vs. Indiana: Coaching, Discipline, and Pressure

The other semifinal might be even more revealing.

Indiana is favored by 3.5 for a reason. They don’t beat themselves. They don’t make mistakes. They’re one of the most disciplined, well-coached teams we’ve seen in years. Watching them dismantle Alabama was a masterclass—three and a half hours of precision, control, and situational dominance.

You don’t stumble into wins like that.

This Indiana team feels like those old Don James Washington teams: great tackling, great special teams, always winning the turnover battle. Maybe not the most talented roster in the country, but always in the right place at the right time. You don’t sneak up on teams like that—you have to beat them decisively.

Oregon, though, is fascinating here.

They’re talented, but flawed. The quarterback still feels young. They can be lured into mistakes. And yet, this is the first time in the Dan Lanning era where Oregon truly gets to play the underdog—not manufactured doubt, real doubt.

Everyone thinks Indiana is winning the national championship

Lanning thrives in these moments. When the speeches aren’t for show. When the disrespect is real. This is new territory for Indiana as well. Curt Cignetti has spent two years punching up. Now everyone expects him to win.

There are reasons for hesitation—Oregon’s coordinators are leaving, the transfer portal grind is real—but the talent gap hasn’t disappeared. Oregon will bring its best.

Fernando Mendoza and the Quarterback Question

As always, the playoff conversation eventually comes back to quarterbacks.

Fernando Mendoza is the most intriguing prospect in this class. The comparisons vary—Matt Ryan, Andrew Luck, Trevor Lawrence—but none are perfect. What matters is the common thread: maturity.

Mendoza feels like a grown-up.

He’s 6’5”, around 240 pounds, strong enough that smaller defenders bounce off him. He’s not Josh Allen as an athlete, and he doesn’t have a pure cannon arm, but he has plenty of juice.

What separates him is what’s upstairs.

Processing. Toughness. Memory.

When he throws a pick-six, he comes right back and drives the field. NFL evaluators love that. They want to see how you respond to failure. They want to see you get hit, get up, and keep throwing.

That Ohio State game told us everything. He took shots early. He got crunched. And he kept making plays. That’s an NFL environment—Seattle, Pittsburgh, Baltimore. Box scores don’t matter in those games. Response does.

Quarterbacking at the highest level is 75 percent mental. Drew Brees said it years ago, and it’s truer than ever. Intelligence. Adaptability. Toughness.

Mendoza may not be an A-plus prospect, but he’s an A. In most drafts, that makes him a legitimate No. 1 or No. 2. Add the character, leadership, and big-game experience, and the projection becomes clear.

Final Thought: The Playoffs as a Blueprint

College football is flattening. Depth charts are thinner. Power is more evenly distributed. Physicality and intelligence matter more than ever. These playoff games aren’t just about who advances—they’re about who understands the new sport.

The teams that adapt fastest, hit hardest, and think best? They’re the ones still standing.

Offered by the Seminole Tribe of Florida in FL. Offered by Seminole Hard Rock Digital, LLC, in all other states. Must be 21+ and physically present in AZ, CO, FL, IL, IN, MI, NJ, OH, TN or VA to play. Terms and conditions apply. Concerned about gambling? In FL, call 1-833-PLAYWISE. In IN, if you or someone you know has a gambling problem and wants help, call 1-800-9-WITH-IT.
GAMBLING PROBLEM? CALL 1‑800‑GAMBLER (AZ, CO, IL, MI, NJ, OH, TN, VA)

Colin Cowherd

Colin Cowherd is the founder of The Volume and the host of The Herd with Colin Cowherd on Fox Sports Radio and FS1. Before launching The Volume, he spent over a decade at ESPN, where he became one of the network’s most recognizable voices. Known for his candid takes and distinctive storytelling, Cowherd has been a leading figure in sports media for more than 20 years.